Friday 19 July 2019

Is the Prize of Cardiff West something Plaid cannot afford?

Neil McEvoy's claim  that there are people at the top of Plaid Cymru who would rather be a junior partner in a coalition with Labour than see their leader as first minister is a typical trope from him.
It is completely unprovable, but still it will resonate with those who see him as Plaid;s only chance of winning the Cardiff West seat in the next assembly elections even if it was to limit Plaid#s advancement elsewhere as he splits the party.
The BBC reports that  Plaid's former AM Neil McEvoy, who recently withdrew his application to rejoin the party  wants to meet Plaid Cymru leader Adam Price for "mediation and a face-to-face meeting".
A Plaid Cymru spokesperson said the party "is unified in its mission to win" the 2021 election.
Earlier this month the controversial politician withdrew his application to re-join the party he was expelled from.
Mr McEvoy has stood for the party in First Minister Mark Drakeford's Cardiff West constituency on a number of occasions, and says only he can win there for Plaid Cymru.
But the former Plaid AM says there are several people within the party who would rather see Mr Drakeford retain his seat and seek a coalition after the next assembly election in 2021.
Mr McEvoy told BBC Wales: "I think the issue really, is whether or not Plaid Cymru wants to win. I'd say the members do, but some people in authority at this moment in the party, do they want to win? Do they want to form a government? I know Adam Price does, I know I do.
"But I think there are some people who would probably be more comfortable being junior partners to Labour and I absolutely oppose that. I want to see Adam Price as first minister, I want to see a Plaid Cymru government but to do that we have to win Cardiff West. And I can."
Asked who he thought was acting in such a way, he added: "Why would anybody at the top of Plaid Cymru try to enable a Labour victory in Cardiff West? it doesn't make sense. The only explanation could be, would be, maybe there's a comfortable deal somewhere and some in Plaid want to be junior partners.
"I think you should ask the chair of Plaid Cymru, Alun Ffred [Jones], you should ask the chief executive. Those are the people who complained about me. Those are the people who want me out.
"Members didn't complain, those people did. And I know Adam wants to win, I want Adam to win, so let's get on with it. Let's get it done."
Plaid Cymru was a junior coalition partner to Labour in the One Wales government from 2007-2011, when Ieuan Wyn Jones served as deputy first minister.
The problem with Mr McEvoys argument   is that his campaigning style is based on populist politics which involves making unfounded accusations about the ruling party and promises that he would find hard to keep.

Indeed it could be argued that like many populist (The Lib Dems often being guilty of this)  ironically prosper in opposition and if given the reins of power will attack their rivals with the claims of Fake News but make no real difference because the power to do so lies elsewhere and thye do not have the finances.

I'd rather it was otherwise  and there was power and finances to make the change, but to make promises that they can't keep is deceiving people.

I do not dismiss Neil McEvoy effectiveness  in Cardifff West and god help us , the Labour Party have a lot to answer for.

However  as in other parts of Wales it means people are not so much Pro Plaid (and independence) as Anti-Labour .

This means that Plaid  have sometimes  "succactually back square Plaid's Independence  stance  or it Progressive policies.

I am not a Plaid member , but it seems to me that already the prize of winning Cardiff West the home of two Labour AMs  has blinded some members  that it may not necessarily benefit the party elsewhere

No comments: